| 1 | CHC | (ATL) | Francisco Liriano, lhp | 11 | BAL | Dustin Pedroia, ss | 21 | CHC | (SF) | Ryan Braun, 3b | 31 | CHC | Dustin Nippert, rhp | |||
| 2 | BAL | (SEA) | Justin Verlander, rhp | 12 | CHC | (SF) | Homer Bailey, rhp | 22 | CHC | Andrew McCutchen, of | 32 | FLA | Alay Soler, rhp | |||
| 3 | CHC | (SF) | Jarrod Saltalamacchia, C | 13 | CHC | Craig Hansen, rhp | 23 | FLA | Jason Hirsh, rhp | 33 | BOS | Miguel Montero, c | ||||
| 4 | CHC | Jeff Clement, C | 14 | FLA | Anibal Sanchez, rhp | 24 | BOS | Edison Volquez, rhp | 34 | FLA | (BAL) | Jeremy Sowers, lhp | ||||
| 5 | FLA | Chuck James, rhp | 15 | BOS | Anthony Reyes, rhp | 25 | BAL | Phil Hughes, rhp | 35 | CHC | (SEA) | Yunel Escobar, ss | ||||
| 6 | BOS | Andy LaRoche, 3b | 16 | BAL | Jered Weaver | 26 | BAL | Eric Campbell, 3b | 36 | CHC | (SF) | Brandon Snyder, c | ||||
| 7 | BAL | (SEA) | Cesar Carrillo, rhp | 17 | BAL | Adam Jones, ss | 27 | BAL | Max Ramirez, c | 37 | FLA | Gio Gonzalez, lhp | ||||
| 8 | CHC | (PHI) | Chris Young, of | 18 | BAL | Elvis Andrus, ss | 28 | CHC | (ATL) | Jay Bruce, of | 38 | BOS | Matt Garza, rhp | |||
| 9 | BOS | Jon Lester, lhp | 19 | CHC | (ATL) | Marcus Sanders, 2B | 29 | CHC | (SEA) | Mike Pelfrey, rhp | 39 | FLA | Jermaine Van Buren, lhp | |||
| 10 | CHC | (ATL) | Troy Tulowitzki, ss | 20 | CHC | (SEA) | Carlos Gonzales, of | 30 | CHC | Scott Olson, lhp | 40 | CHC | (SF) | Colby Rasmus, of | ||
| 41 | CHC | Troy Patton, lhp | 51 | BOS | Cliff Pennington, ss | |||||||||||
| 42 | FLA | Shane Lindsey, rhp | 52 | CHC | Andre Ethier, of | |||||||||||
| 43 | BOS | Melkey Cabrera, of | 53 | BOS | C.J. Henry, ss | |||||||||||
| 44 | FLA | Clay Bucholtz, rhp | 54 | CHC | Jairo Garcia, rhp | |||||||||||
| 45 | CHC | (SF) | Mark Pawelek, lhp | 55 | BOS | Jacoby Ellsbury, cf | ||||||||||
| 46 | CHC | Chris Iannetta, c | 56 | CHC | Hung-Chin Kuo, lhp | |||||||||||
| 47 | FLA | Hunter Pence, OF | 57 | BOS | Mark Rogers, lhp | |||||||||||
| 48 | BOS | Ricky Ronero, lhp | 58 | CHC | Blake DeWitt, 3b | |||||||||||
| 49 | CHC | Jonathan Broxton, rhp | 59 | BOS | Joe Saunders, lhp | |||||||||||
| 50 | CHC | Brad Snyder, of | 60 | BOS | Nick Adenhart, p | |||||||||||
| 61 | BOS | Kevin Melillo, 2b | ||||||||||||||
| 62 | BOS | Eddy Martinez-Esteve, of | ||||||||||||||
| 63 | BOS | John Mayberry Jr., of | ||||||||||||||
| BAL | 9 | |||||||||||||||
| BOS | 17 | |||||||||||||||
| CHC | 27 | |||||||||||||||
| FLA | 10 | |||||||||||||||
| 63 | ||||||||||||||||